Cargin gets the vote from the majority of ‘experts’

Saffron Gael reporter Brendan McTaggart asked some people connected with the game, players, managers and ‘experts who would take home the silverware on Sunday. To his credit he gave his own opinion first

Brendan McTaggart – Saffron Gael

It’s got all the ingredients to be a cracking contest. Two rivals, separated by a river and bragging rights are up for grabs. Cargin have went about their league campaign quietly without ripping up the trees as in previous years. It’s clear they’ve been gearing towards peaking at the championship and in Damian Cassidy they have a manager who can prime a squad for the business end when it matters most. Sunday will be the culmination of the better part of three years work for Kevin Madden and his side. They have looked a different animal all year but they will have to dig deeper than ever before to get one over their neighbours. If they can get their attacking game flowing early doors as they have shown all year, they will cause Cargin problems. They have dangerous options everywhere you look and the ability to adapt when the occasion arises but Cargin have the experience that on the day, can be the difference. There won’t be much in it, I genuinely think it could come down to whoever makes less mistakes or whoever creates that little piece of magic. If I’m pushed, I’ll go with Cargin but don’t be surprised if we need another 60 minutes.

Verdict – Cargin

Patrick Gallagher – Glenavy

Two quality teams so it’s very hard to call. Creggan are on the crest of a wave while Cargin have been there and done that and have all the experience. I think the biggest factors will be Cargin’s match-ups versus the Small’s and if Creggan have someone to stop Mick McCann. I think Marty Johnston could be called to do that job at some point. Creggan to sneak home by two but I wouldn’t put money on it!

Verdict – Creggan

Paddy Nugent – Aldergrove manager

The game will be very physical especially in the opening quarter. It may well come down to who has the strongest bench. Cargin have the greater experience and that may prove to be the difference on the day.

Verdict – Cargin

CJ McGourty – St Galls

I think Creggan go into the game as slight favourites based on their form but Cargin have improved as the year has progressed. It will be very close but it will come down to 1) Can Creggan cope with their first final in 40 years versus Cargins experience and 2) Can Cargin’s big players do it again? I’m calling a draw and it’s not to sit on the fence, it’s an honest opinion.

Verdict – Draw

Niall McKeever – Portglenone

This is a really tough one to call. Creggan have been the form team across Antrim all year and are up against a Cargin team that have been there and done it. If Creggan get their match ups correct, play the brand of football they’ve been playing throughout the year, I see them edging it by a couple of points. They’re really well set up, solid at the back and going forward have multiple players that can all be a threat. They’ve beaten Cargin a couple of times already this year and with a young team that will give them confidence. I wouldn’t rule out a draw but I think Creggan will win by two or three points in a high scoring game with plenty of goals.

Verdict – Creggan

Sean McVeigh – Ballymena

I fancy Cargin to win by a small margin. Their experience on the pitch and of the occasion will stand by them. They have key players in every line of the pitch but it should be a cracker of a game.

Verdict – Cargin

Stephen Beatty – Rossa

As we’ve been out of the championship early doors, I’ve had plenty of time to watch all the games with my Da. I’m sure everyone will agree that Creggan have been the best team all year but I think Cargin have been riding their luck against Lámh Dhearg and of course with Tomás’ goal against St Galls. The fact that they haven’t hit top form and still make the final makes me feel like they will get the job done come Sunday.

Verdict – Cargin

Kevin Herron – Saffron Gael

I’m going for the underdog and backing Creggan. Everyone loves an underdog story and what a story this could be. 41 years since their last appearance in the final and Kevin Madden turning 41 recently – it must be an omen. I’ve only had the chance to watch Creggan four times this season but they’ve been very impressive. They’ve played with a swagger and a confidence I’ve never saw before against Lámh Dhearg on both occasions and in the first half against St Galls in a league game at Milltown and also showed against St Johns that they are able to see a game out. As a youngster I enjoyed a phase of playing in goals and Sean McGreevy was my favourite Antrim player but Kevin Madden wasn’t far behind and is up there among my favourites in a Saffron jersey. It would be great to see Kevin and Creggan get their hands on the Padriag McNamee Cup on Sunday.

Verdict – Creggan

Paddy Tierney – Belfast Media Group

It’s hard to look past Cargin for this one. They defeated last years champions Lámh Dhearg after a replay and a late Tomás McCann goal gave them the most dramatic win possible over St Galls in the semi-final. To concede four goals and still win takes some doing. Few teams would have recovered as often as Cargin did in that game. Creggan have shown fine form in the league and they have the talent up front to pose serious questions of Cargin’s back line. They won’t lack confidence following their gutsy win over St Johns in the last four however you have to go back to experience and Cargin have been there and done it. Creggan may have to lose one before getting their hands on the McNamee Cup. Cargin by four.

Verdict – Cargin

David Mohan – Belfast Media Group

It may be cliche to say it’s ‘all on the day’, but one can’t shake that feeling when it comes to picking a winner of Sunday’s final.

While Cargin have held something of an Indian sign over Creggan in the Championship in recent times, Kickham’s have never been too far away in meetings between the pair and I can’t see there being much in this one either.

The fact this is a final should mean they go in with an extra spring in their step rather than be engulfed with expectation given they finally got over the semi-final hump against the Johnnies last time out to reach their first final since 1977 and will believe they can now go all the way and win the MacNamee Cup for the first time since 1954.

Creggan certainly have the talent with the Smalls, McCanns and Johnstons all established names on the Antrim landscape, while Cargin have their own marquee players with Jamie Gribbin, Michael Magill, Michael McCann and James Laverty all playing some top stuff. Add in Tomás McCann who has grabbed the headlines with that semi-final winner and also his equaliser in the quarter-final and you have a team who appear to be primed to reclaim the title they last held two years ago.

I don’t believe the occasion will get to Creggan. There are players lining out who claimed an All-Ireland Junior title four years ago, so a local derby in familiar surroundings shouldn’t register too much.

Still, the manner in which Cargin have got to the final, eliminating the defending champions and then edging home in the semi-final thriller leads me to believe their name is on the cup and may edge it by the minimum. But I’m not ruling out Creggan in any way, shape or form.

Verdict – Cargin

Liam Tunney – Unit Updates

This is a very hard one to call. Both sides are well worth their place in this year’s decider and have been among the top three sides in the county this season, with the Creggan lads winning the league and O’Cahan Cup, where they of course beat Cargin in the final.

Cargin’s league campaign was torpedoed by injury but they turned adversity into advantage, spreading game time throughout the squad and building resilience. That resilience was clear as they battled through a replay to beat Lámh Dhearg and saw off St Gall’s with the last kick.

The billing of Madden v Cassidy is an intriguing one, but the men on the pitch will ultimately have the final say. I feel Cargin’s greater experience at this stage will be telling and having slipped up last year, they will be determined to win back their crown. Cargin by a slim margin.

Verdict – Cargin

Gearóid Adams – St John’s manager

I think this game could go right to the wire. Cargin will have tremendous believe due to the nature of their win over St Galls while Creggan have been the most consistent team this year. There will be some tremendous battles with the likes of Ruairi McCann or Conor McCann marking Tómas McCann, Ricky Johnston on Michael Magill. It’ll be interesting to see the match ups from both managers, particularly who Kevin chooses to mark Mick McCann, who continues to be the heartbeat of the Cargin team, and who Damian picks to man mark both Conor and Kevin Small. Kobo and James Laverty could well get these roles. The match, however, could be decided by one of the younger players from either team. Young Gribben and Bradley have impressed for Cargin in their championship run, and for Creggan young Liam Quinn is an excellent forward with pace and guile to unhinge any defence. This is going to be a tight encounter with the local rivalry between both clubs adding a bit of spice to the mix. I think the team who hold their nerve best will ultimately win this game. Both teams showed great resolve in their semi final wins and this game could go down to a bit of luck, an individual mistake or a fortunate decision from the man in the middle. It is going to be an intriguing encounter.

Verdict – Sitting on the fence


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.